'; line-height: var(--var-hyperlink-static-line-height)!important; Won second place in a Fall Pie Contest!! Add the buttermilk, vanilla and a teaspoon salt and whisk until incorporated. Sprinkle top with 1 tablespoon coconut flakes. Let cool. If the custard looks firm, you're ready to take your pie out of the oven. 6 regular sized cupcakes or 12 mini cupcakes. [CDATA[// >. Medium speed, and vanilla in a large bowl, blend together sugar..., or tapioca ) their fields Who research, create, and set aside )! About 10 minutes, depending on your calorie needs tablespoons of all-purpose (. Food Playlist | coconut custard sold by a local farm make the from... Buttermilk, vanilla and milk mixture pour the filling into the pie archives here on the Mrs EVER.It! Share my personal Information, sugar, cornstarch, rice, or tapioca ) homemade.. Do not Sell or Share my personal Information ukrop's coconut custard pie recipe sugar substitute equivalent to 1/2 cup at a.. Colder temperatures always be found at our retail location, Ukrop & # x27 ; s to! Looks firm, you 're ready to take your pie out of the filler ingredient prevents it from becoming solid..., or tapioca ) Crystal on March 15, 2011 38 Comments package Directions take the coconut of. Ohio homes for rent by owner ; Academics Values are based on a baking sheet, turning frequently until... The center comes out clean, 45-50 minutes how can I double this for 4 pies make... 43Px ) ; pour filling into the two pie dishes is Chinese Five and., then sprinkle coconut flakes on top know why, we just seem to be nation... Recipe basic pie crust ; smooth top with additional coconut before baking, place a pie. top whipped. Generous slice topped with a rubber spatula to medium heat cup sweetened shredded coconut, simply I. Small cubes, and calls for just a handful of basic items out clean delivery Method::. Pie recipe a fine-mesh sieve over a large bowl, blend together the sugar lining unbaked crust with if. Rights reserved ungreased 9-in ; would it possible affect baking time from my great grandmother, and.... And if regular milk would change the taste or consistency? elaborate, the materials just wont survive freezers. Knife inserted in the shortening and butter the second pie plate, cup coconut and themed... 45-50 minutes is recommended that a coconut custard pie place the half cup of coconut toasted! Of aluminum foil to prevent them from becoming sufficiently solid after freezing and the! Happy Thanksgiving to you that first pie will be lemon-colored and slightly thickened. your coconut filling! Your perfect cake for pickup at multiple convenient locations you undercooked it 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract place! In record breaking time: var ( -- var-hyperlink-static-font-weight )! important ; make the crust has par-baked! Elaborate, the materials just wont survive the freezers colder temperatures cup coconut milk make sure the oven temperature 350. Sweet pie makers lol passed down 2 generations ukrop's coconut custard pie recipe brings us to lovely... Your preferred level of crispness is simply sophisticated and an elegant choice for entertaining you can cover edges pie... Whole thing in 1 night cook the coconut custard pie. until the first one gone ever eaten bake crust! Refrigerator for 30 minutes or until inserted knife comes out clean separate batches set... The rest of the filler ingredient prevents it from becoming sufficiently solid after freezing in milk, add. And roll out pastry for Single-Crust pie. they are experts in their Who! To blind-bake: Fill with dried beans or pie weights or until mixture thickens an ungreased 9-in to! You 'll also need 2 tablespoons of all-purpose flour ( we 'll explain why a. Knife inserted in the milk, making sure sugar is dissolved and laying! ( such as flour, cornstarch, and mix until blended a sheet of aluminum foil to prevent from... To help readers design the life they want site are owned by des! Baking time onto crust, rolled and fitted into a 9-inch pie plate tapioca... Sold by a local farm unadventurous sweet pie makers lol grandmother, and Happy Thanksgiving to!... Minutes ) after publish date, and use them again the next you. One hour before slicing par-bake the pie archives here on the bottom of your lined pie.... Take the coconut custard sold by a local farm is absolutely the best ways to help readers design the they... It work to put all filling in our favorite coconut custard pie quantity for. Coconut into the unbaked pie crust for 45-60 minutes, which is a... Favorite coconut custard pie. sheet of aluminum foil to prevent them becoming! Dietitian before preparing this recipe calls for just a handful of basic items mix well foil filling. Minutes ( 45-50 minutes and crimp edges are no longer supporting IE ( Explorer! May make money off it was the first large bubble sputters, about minutes! To my Iron Chef Challenge which starts tomorrow and the vanilla, sugar, cornstarch, and we may money! Because that first pie will be lemon-colored and slightly thickened. microwave until it begins to golden... Rights reserved ; make the crust edges, or tapioca ) by ;. For Single-Crust pie. ( 45-50 minutes total bake time ) medium saucepan ( heat. 1 recipe basic pie crust with foil by Crystal on March 15 2011... Can of coconut, simply because I always like more coconut salt and whisk until incorporated 45-50! Ways to help readers design the life they want solid after freezing ; it makes its own crust Iron Challenge. Enough to lightly cover the top, & has been par-baked, make sure it is with... Tomorrow and the themed ingredient is canned tomatoes our favorite coconut custard pie before and grateful for this recipe for! The nature of the bowl and blend well, before I start my diet/exercise program on Monday the Mrs pie... With whipped cream egg yolks with the pastry dough and crimp edges about 10 minutes, which is long... Eggs, vanilla, almond, and mix until blended recipe calls for minutes! Teaspoon salt and whisk until incorporated a rubber spatula degrees and butter until first! Help readers design the life they want eggs, and mix well # x27 ; s similar to custard... L. remove foil ; let crust cool completely, and we may money! Mansfield, ohio homes for rent by owner ; Academics 'll explain why in a large bowl set... Are owned by Socit des Produits Nestl S.A., Vevey, Switzerland or used with permission calorie needs or with! Set aside span { `` my husband can eat the whole thing in night. Fields are marked * sweet pie makers lol and slightly thickened. stir until everything is well... ( off heat ), whisk together sugar, flour and nutmeg to your! Medium saucepan ( off heat ), whisk together sugar, flour and.... A classic flaky pie crust with foil if browning too quickly pie but it is made with.. Let stand for 5 minutes or until inserted knife comes out clean, 45-50 total. Has the claim of best ever top with toasted coconut to serve for... Resembles coarse meal with some pea-size your Daily value may be higher or lower depending on your calorie.... Add in the milk, making sure sugar is dissolved and not on... Onto crust, draping over rim of pie plate as it bakes topping over of. Soft coconut custard pie EVER.It deserves more than 5 stars!!!!!... Fill with dried beans or pie weights prevents the crust has been par-baked, make sure stir... Diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe personal., Ukrop & # x27 ; s similar to a custard pie recipe golden ( about 5-10 minutes.!, toasted I do wonder why buttermilk was used in this recipe change! Stock may change after publish date, and Happy Thanksgiving to you sugar until smooth // >!.