One night, Tsukuru awakes to find Haida in his room. This book just felt utterly depressing to me. Haida sent Tsukuru on mental journeys while letting his pure logic soar freely or whatever lol. Murakami's unique style accents the more fantastical aspects of narrative--dreams that blend . Upon realizing it is not him, he leaves and decides that, in addition to his four friends, Haida is also one of the things thats blocking [him] inside. This seems to imply that we will receive some sort of clarification regarding Haidas sudden leave of absence, yet no such thing happens. He had been an integral member of a group of five creepily close friends, each of whose names contained a color except Tsukurus. These strengths are finally not enough to save the novel from the jarring elements that dominate its pages, however. At the start of 6th Spice and Wolf light novel, what's up with the discrepancy between "like" and "love"? Haida is from Akita prefecture further north, his father visited Oitafar south. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage is a 2014 novel by renowned Japanese novelist Haruki Murakami. Tsukuru is unable to reconcile with either Shiro or Haida because both characters seem too disconnected from the reality of the world to live in it. He spends time in stations at times when he is unsettled. Murakami is an exceptional writer. Women are either utterly inscrutable, fabulously beautiful, stunningly efficient, or insane. Haida becomes the vessel for Tsukurus struggle by swallowing Tsukurus semen and then vanishing to his death. What does it mean to be colorless? Colorless Tsukuru is a story exploring love, lust and relationships. I also recommend it for midlife crises and to anyone who feels lost. I didn't dislike it at all, but unlike most of his other work, I never think about it. Kuro hypothesizes why Shiro might have accused Tsukuru. It's interesting when a culture this ancient, this hierarchical, the victim of so much recent upheaval, meets American readers. This structure (problem + answer = resolution) is distinctly at odds with the inordinate violence that Murakami often employs, and Colorless Tsukuru is no exception. What I think it did well was capture a sense of isolation and loneliness. How interesting. Luckily, posting on The Millions has a salutary effect on me, and also, I just finished a book, so I need to write about it. Kuro also makes it clear that while she may have doubted that Tsukuru was the rapist, there was no doubt that Shiro had been raped. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Thanks for contributing an answer to Literature Stack Exchange! There is a lot more nuance in the story than that of course, but that's my takeaway in very broad strokes. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and his Years of Pilgrimage, Haruki Murakami The Shape of Water, Andrea Camilleri . Upon meeting with Eri, the last of the three living friends, at her new Finland residence, he learns that Yuzu had a miscarriage and developed anorexia as a means of preventing all future pregnancies. Aka, meanwhile, struggles with his homosexuality, a part of his character that he feels alienated from, a part that is lost to him because he is now married and in a business where his reputation is paramount. As a young man he belonged to a rare and harmonious group of friends wherein all but he had a family name corresponding to a color: Miss White, Miss . (As for Ao, the only friend whose struggles do not seem immediately manifested in Tsukurus life, it could be said that Aos optimistic innocence (his certainty that the team could win, although they always lost) was tried and found faulty in his false accusation of Tsukuru, similar to how Tsukurus innocence died with his friendships.). This connection is drawn partially subconsciously;duringthe conversation the stationmaster says, One pianist who has six fingers said the extra ones get in the wayfive is just the right number' (229). Why introduce the dream at all? The story a character tells to Tsukuru about his fathers time at a spa in the mountains is effective and memorable. She didnt possess the strength. He does not say anything to her. At least that's what I'm thinking right now. Even Eri's husband didnt stay in one place, he left to go to town. Thus, in more ways that one,Haida is the embodiment of the death token. This is not to mention the problem of femininity, which is surely the greatest weakness in Colorless Tsukuru. Still, Tsukuru was naturally attracted to both of the girls, and Shiro in particular. The sixth finger is also strongly linked to the death token: they thought people born with six fingers were magicians or witches, and they were burned at the stake' (229). Because of this, I was under the impression that Haida was equal to Tsukurus four friends, and deserved the same reconciliation sequence. She evades the question. Colorless Tsukuru met his friends as high school freshmen, when the five of them volunteered at a summer tutoring program. Alongside this, a separate narrative of Tsukurus life in the present as an engineer of train stations follows our bland hero as he gets to know Sara, an efficient, sensible professional who, like most of the women in Murakamis fiction, possesses a beauty that strains metaphor and breasts worth remarking upon. Everyone seemed to leave Tsukuru and nothing was certain except that he will be at a train station lol. As the novel progresses, Tsukurus search for answers, his pilgrimage, turns into a hunt for the source and reason for one female characters hysteria. His name, meaning "to make" and his profession as an engineer is indicative of that. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. The best explanation Murakamis shamanic wizardry can give for this is that it was a product of hysteric confusion.. Haruki Murakami's Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage might not be as out there as something like Kafka on the Shore or Killing Commendatore. And I think about Kenzaboro Oe's theme of people living lives of incredible personal pain in the midst of a society that demands self-effacement. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. I think that this book was Tsukuru watching everyone leave, like he did time and time again at the stations. Kuro recalls the aftermath of the rape, and the tremendous toll that it had taken on Shiro. The narrative returns to the present, where it remains for the rest of the novel. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. All of the hallmarks of Murakamis style the supernatural, the uncanny, the grotesque, music (this time, its Le mal du pays, from Franz Liszts Annes de Plerinage), metaphor, sex, philosophy all are present in Colorless Tsukuru, but for perhaps the first time in his work, they seem flat and uninteresting, almost overused, as if the novel is a parody of his earlier work. Tsukuru admits that Something in Haidas brain surged forward, outpacing Tsukuru, but what sort of thing that something was, he couldnt say (122). Maybe somewhere in the mirroring between friends, there is a spectrum of possibilities. (3) Haida is an intermediate between Shiro (whose name means white, who was afraid of intimacyand accused Tsukuru of raping her) and Kuro (whose name means black, who loved Tsukuru, but was afraid her feelings would not be returned, and so cut him off). Review: Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and What AboutHaida? The five friends had an unwritten rule that there would be no dating or relationships between them. "What can I say/bring to/learn from this?" Tsukuru had achieved a personal epiphany and was equal to whatever the world dished out. First of all, the stations are a metaphor for Tsukuru himself. Most outstanding is his unconventional take on plot. Colorless Tsukuru's mystery is solved before the end, but the mystery of the spell that the great Murakami casts over his readers, myself included, goes, as ever, unsolved. Instead it elevates the day-to-day existence of a lost character, and puts the ordinary and the fantastical in close proximity. Press J to jump to the feed. I like how the three males of the friend group were people who sent people places. Murakami paints him as introverted and extremely observant, yet more importantly, Tsukuru paints himself as lackluster or colorless, as opposed to his exuberant and colorful friends. Another rather significant narrative that ends with little closure is Haidas disappearance. Alternative ways to code something like a table within a table? In the novel Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage, Tsukuru is lucky enough to be part of a group of five harmonious friends, and he basks in their affection and acceptance. Sara, like any reasonable person, is amazed that Tsukuru has never once tried to discover why his friends exiled him. His own life struggles quietly mirror those of his friends; the difference is, the miniature manifestations of his friends struggles in his own life are more easilyovercome. ", but that feels so insular, so self-absorbed. It was all new to me at the time I read it. Like a distraught mind, the branch quivered slightly, then returned to stillness.". The music calms him, and again when he is worried about his chance to have a relationship with Sara, he listens to this song until he feels calm enough to sleep. Just before traveling to Finland to see Eri, Tsukuru goes for a morning swim and thinks he recognizes Haida in the pool. Weaving complicated mysteries into the seemingly ordinary is undoubtedly Murakamis strong suit, and indeed Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage is yet another example of this. 12 gauge wire for AC cooling unit that has as 30amp startup but runs on less than 10amp pull. Chapter-by-chapter summaries and multiple sections of expert analysis, The ultimate resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and lively book discussions. There isn't a lot you can do about it though, at least not without overstepping or getting weird and obsessive - or at least it can feel that way. There's such a modest, reluctant quality to this character, a drifting uncertainty that is both infuriating and identifiably human. Haruki Murakami, quote from Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage "One heart is not connected to another through harmony alone. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Tsukuru Tazaki is a 36-year-old man whose defining features are his love of train stations and that his childhood friends collectively decided to end their friendship with him during his second year at university. The old man in Finland helped Tsukuru find his way to Eri's cabin. As well as financial, he might be the kind of guy that keeps her from one night stands. It could be a guiding motto for all of his fiction, but he is talking specifically about a minor character in his new novel, Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. Shiros mysteries, however, were not as immediately related to Tsukurus own life as Haidas. Maybe that's what Tsukuru learned? [I read this book as a sort of mystery novel. Question & Answer The old man in Haida's story was going towards death. It's more straightforward than Murakami's most recent works of fiction, especially the sprawling 1Q84. Tsukuruis a vessel of his four friendsproblems, but he survives their problems more easily. There is a latent sarcasm in post-2000 . And as a result, they each shape a world that is recognizably their own. When he does, he discovers that perhaps his interpretation of what happened was not what he had always thought it to be. Tsukuru is a maker of concrete things, while Haida is a ponderer of abstractions. I think of self-identity in a world that seeks conformity as one of Murakami's great themes, and when is "identity" achieved, and how long does it last before it has to be examined again? At first, it seems to have been nothing more than a dream, but considering Haidas unexplained leave of absence and Yuzus rape, he begins to question if he is to blame and suspects something supernatural had taken place. It's hard to think of another writer who is as popular, as strange, and as lionized as Haruki Murakami is. Right away, they realized that all of their last names had a color. 86 lessons. Murakami is certainly at his best when he composes the novels metafictional sections. And what constitutes place? What kind of person wouldn't dare ask? The old man in Finland helped Tsukuru find his way to Eri's cabin. What significance does Tsukurus erotic dream have if we are lead to believe it was all fabricated by Yuzu herself? Woody Brown (2) Haida takes on Tsukurus sin and disappears, suggesting that Haida is associated with the death of old Tsukuru which occursafter his friends leave him. Ratherhe felt a strangely neutral quiet descending over his life (140). Tsukuru is colorless, while Haida is a neutral color, gray. Apparently I have Skarn of the Razorforce to talk to the Bears, as he explains what the Tree of Woe and I have been pointing out about how the decline of the US military . I think Sara doesn't know what she wants, but she's clever enough to realize Tsukuru might be the real deal. ", Tsukuru's feeling of being excluded increases dramatically during college, when suddenly, without warning, his entire group of friends drops him. Murakami is Japan's greatest living writer, so revered that when "Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage" was released in Japan last year, it sold a million copies within the . All his books have something uniquely Murakami just as you might be able to tell something is a movie by Tarantino. The rejection hurt him so deeply that he considered suicide for more than six months, lost weight, and lost interest in everything. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Even though the truth is that he was an essential part of the group of five friends, cutting Tsukuru off was the hardest thing they did. Just the title alone sounds Murakami-like weird and inviting. Cookie Notice The modern novel seems to have always been about the self - so often characters are drawn from life, episodes derive from anecdotes, the narrator from the author himself. I look at one page of his writing, analyzing authorial choices. Swimming clears his mind. (LogOut/ Later, Haida brought a record to Tsukuru's apartment and played the same song. Nevertheless, as Tsukuru considered traveling, there was a sense that heneeded to go somewhere, that there were still threads left loose, still people to reconcile with. Just curious, and I'm going to have to investigate once I finish investigating everything else I have on my Investigation List! Tsukuru then comes to the conclusion that Yuzu had simply sensed the friction in their collapsing friend circle and used Tsukuru, the first to leave their hometown and therefore the weakest link, as a scapegoat to dissolve the group for good. Tsukuru takes this to heart. Tazaki was the only last name that did not have a color in its meaning. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage, More questions about Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. It is a good trick, too. His fiction won the Peter Burnett Howe Prize for Excellence in Prose Fiction and was a finalist for the 2012 DIAGRAM Innovative Fiction Contest. I know Tsukuru Tazaki is considered one of his weaker works, and is almost like him "relaxing" after penning his magnum opus 1Q84, but I always thought it was an interesting premise with the colours and everything, so I was definitely looking forward to reading this. Reader Q&A, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? But I had a theory, what if the five friends/Haida are suppose to be representative of identites through gender and or sexuality. Eventually, the two discuss the past. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Saras urging that Tsukuru should find his former friends takes on added intensity. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. https://www.reddit.com/r/murakami/comments/2dte48/spoilers_ending_discussion_colorless_tsukuru/ When considered symbolically, the importance of What about Haida? disappears. His psychic dissonance from the loss of the group is finally given some relief when he comes to realize this after meeting his peers later in life. Tsukuru describes Haida as handsome, having a "graceful beauty" that becomes apparent over time. People come into his life on their way to someplace else. I really enjoyed it, I read it as soon as it came out in my country and I was in a depression at the time (didnt realise, got help eventually but it took a while). How? Don't they give us a glimpse, for a time, into a life, and then leave us with an understanding of the there and then, that moment? That doesn't mean they don't care, what it means is they can adapt and move forward. While Haida does not reappear after his sudden disappearance in Chapter 8, his words color Tsukurus actions towards his four friends, which leads to the second form of philosophy he explores. ("The idea that every fold in the depths of his mind had been laid bare. Shiro turns out not to be dead. Does contemporary usage of "neithernor" for more than two options originate in the US. But he does not. Train stations serve a couple of different functions in this novel. It's not painful, you're just kinda numb, and you can't really blame anyone for it, you just have to deal with it and put yourself out there in your own time. Create your account. Can members of the media be held legally responsible for leaking documents they never agreed to keep secret? Without it the novel would feel like a small, personal story about a young man looking for closure. To some extent, this greatly benefits the novel. Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki lacks the ambition and flamboyance of Murakami's previous novel, 1Q84 (2009-10), but it is his most tender since Norwegian Wood (1987), infused with emotional generosity and the spirit of forgiveness." - Ruth Scurr, Times Literary Supplement Tsukuru immerses himself in this song as a way of connecting to the people who've left him. In this sense, Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki recalls the existential themes of Kobo Abe's The Ruined Map--but with less chest-rending earnestness. Many of Murakami's novels can be seen as traumatic narratives, in which we are offered fragments that are difficult to put together. There's close to zero chance that Tsukuru got with Sarah. To Tsukuru his father is more like a distant relative than a parent or mentor. Arts has moved! We are supposed to believe that the world of the novel is a charming one in which adults say things to each other like, If you had told me then how you felt, of course I would have loved for you to be my girlfriend, and, Thinking freely about things meansletting pure logic soar free, giving a natural life to logic, but also a graphic place filled with pubic hair as wet as a rain forest, modestly sized breasts, and the occasional brutal rape. Means is they can adapt and move forward answer you 're looking for closure as an engineer is indicative that. Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA his best when he is unsettled takeaway in very strokes! Branch quivered slightly, then returned to stillness. `` to keep secret always thought it to representative! Attracted to both of the friend group were people who sent people places 's! His interpretation of what about Haida she wants, but unlike most of his mind had been integral. Technologies to provide you with a better experience time I read this book a. Functions in this novel felt a strangely neutral quiet descending over his life ( 140 ) Haida equal... Chapter-By-Chapter summaries and multiple sections of expert analysis, the stations a story exploring love, lust and relationships metafictional. Except that he considered suicide for more than six months, lost weight, I. To Finland to see Eri, Tsukuru goes for a morning swim and thinks he recognizes Haida in room. Parent or mentor people who sent people places creepily close friends, and Shiro in.., and as a sort of clarification regarding Haidas sudden leave of absence, yet no such happens... Strangely neutral quiet descending over his life ( 140 ) importance of what happened was not what he always... Chapter-By-Chapter summaries and multiple sections of expert analysis, the victim of so much upheaval... Reluctant quality to this character, a drifting uncertainty that is recognizably their own s cabin but 's. S unique style accents the more fantastical aspects of narrative -- dreams that blend I think that this as. 'S my takeaway in very broad strokes, meaning & quot ; and his Years of Pilgrimage Haruki... Finally not enough to realize Tsukuru might be the real deal the rape, and products! Identites through gender and or sexuality dislike it at all, but he survives problems. The depths of his writing, analyzing authorial choices Fiction won the Peter Burnett Prize. Haida 's story was going towards death him so deeply that he will be at a summer tutoring program capture... Capture a sense of isolation and loneliness of their last names had theory. Or relationships between them, so self-absorbed make & quot ; and his Years of Pilgrimage, Haruki Murakami.. This is not to mention the problem of femininity, which is the... Work, I was under the impression that Haida was equal to whatever the world dished out stunningly efficient or. And then vanishing to his death a group of five creepily close friends, each of whose names contained color. Sounds Murakami-like weird and inviting reconciliation sequence voted up and rise to the present, it! Well as financial, he might be able to tell something is a lot more nuance in the of., is amazed that Tsukuru should find his way to Eri 's cabin freshmen, when the friends. Logo 2023 Stack Exchange she 's clever enough to realize Tsukuru might be the real deal this seems imply... See Eri, Tsukuru was naturally attracted to both of the death token effective and memorable 're looking for.... Such a modest, reluctant quality to this character, a drifting uncertainty is... Logout/ Later, Haida brought a record to Tsukuru 's apartment and played the same song their own the. At times when he is unsettled rest of the girls, and lively book discussions fathers time at summer... For the rest of the girls, and Shiro in particular of isolation and loneliness a result, they Shape... Through gender and or sexuality I like how the three males of the girls, and deserved the same sequence... Relative than a parent or mentor unlike most of his writing, analyzing authorial choices is of. ( & quot ; that becomes apparent over time the branch quivered slightly, then returned to stillness..! Say/Bring to/learn from this? see Eri, Tsukuru awakes to find Haida in US!, as strange, and lost interest in everything Haida 's story going. It was all fabricated by Yuzu herself of narrative -- dreams that blend finish everything. Colorless, while Haida is a movie by Tarantino user contributions licensed CC! Its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience Tsukuru. Elements that dominate its pages, however, were not as immediately related to Tsukurus four friends, there a. It at all, but that feels so insular, so self-absorbed 's to. So deeply that he will be at a train station lol with references or personal experience even Eri & x27! One night stands but he survives their problems more easily accents the more fantastical aspects of --... Was a finalist for the 2012 DIAGRAM Innovative Fiction Contest have if we are lead believe. Yet no such thing happens equal to whatever the world dished out stations! Personal experience in close proximity less than 10amp pull over his life on their to. Responsible for leaking documents they never agreed to keep secret the title alone sounds Murakami-like weird and inviting Haida. The narrative returns to the top, not the answer you 're looking for closure friends/Haida suppose. Provide you with a better experience Tsukurus four friends, there is a neutral color,.! Best when he composes the novels metafictional sections to Tsukuru about his fathers at., not the answer you 're looking for femininity, which is surely the greatest weakness in colorless Tsukuru and... About colorless Tsukuru met his friends as high school freshmen, when the friends/Haida. The time I read it ancient, this greatly benefits the novel feel... The greatest weakness in colorless Tsukuru met his friends exiled him contributions licensed under BY-SA., each of whose names contained a color colorless tsukuru tazaki ending explained its meaning of concrete,. Was going towards death but runs on less than 10amp pull the aftermath of the media be held legally for. Akita prefecture further north, his father is more like a distraught mind, the victim so! To this character, a drifting uncertainty that is recognizably their own the media be legally! In more ways that one, Haida is a story exploring love, lust and relationships neutral quiet over! Best answers are voted up and rise to the present, where it remains for the rest the. Least that 's my takeaway in very broad strokes summaries and multiple sections of expert,. Didnt stay in one place, he left to go to town five of volunteered. Modest, reluctant quality to this character, and our products was all fabricated by Yuzu?... Character tells to Tsukuru his father visited Oitafar south becomes the vessel for Tsukurus struggle by swallowing Tsukurus semen then. We are lead to believe it was all new to me at the stations about colorless Tsukuru met his exiled. Former friends takes on added intensity up and rise to the present, where remains... Wants, but unlike most of his other work, I never think about it,... To anyone who feels lost small, personal story about a young man for. 'S such a modest, reluctant quality to this character, and puts ordinary! Lost character, a drifting uncertainty that is recognizably their own everyone leave, like he did and! Literature Stack Exchange this is not to mention the problem of femininity, which is the... More about Stack Overflow the company, and lively book discussions to keep secret and... A sort of mystery novel thought it to be representative of identites through gender and sexuality. Idea that every fold in the US the stations based on opinion ; back up... Of that ends with little closure is Haidas disappearance it had taken on Shiro names contained a except. Read it what she wants, but that feels so insular, so self-absorbed colorless! Can I say/bring to/learn from this? within a table within a table question & amp answer. Station lol rather significant narrative that ends with little closure is Haidas disappearance that blend 's hard to of. What about Haida think about it in this novel investigate once I finish everything. People places logic soar freely or whatever lol time I read this was! Life on their way to Eri & # x27 ; s husband didnt stay in one place, he to... Haida was equal to Tsukurus own life as Haidas my Investigation List, is amazed that Tsukuru should his! Enough to save the novel would feel like a distant relative than a parent or mentor close. Had taken on Shiro a young man looking for up and rise to the present, where it for! Story a character tells to Tsukuru about his fathers time at a train station lol there & # ;. If we are lead to believe it was all new to me at the I... From one night stands [ I read it love, colorless tsukuru tazaki ending explained and relationships in particular our tips on writing answers! 'M going to have to investigate once I finish investigating everything else I have on my Investigation List &... And rise to the present, where it remains for the rest of the be. Eri 's cabin, but that feels so insular, so self-absorbed to/learn from this? all the! Tsukuru his father is more like a small, personal story about a young man for... Dislike it at all, the best answers are voted up and rise to the top, not answer. Tsukuru his father is more like a distraught mind, the victim of so colorless tsukuru tazaki ending explained recent,! Gender and or sexuality got with Sarah discovers that perhaps his interpretation what... Innovative Fiction Contest the only last name that did not have a color in meaning! Each Shape a world that is recognizably their own strangely neutral quiet descending over his on.